the albany project

behind that door are three five men in a room...


Español


About
The Albany Project seeks to return New York State Government to its rightful owners - the people.

Getting Started at the Albany Project

Resources
- Searchable Senate Pork Data (2004-2005) - On-line

- Searchable Senate Pork Data (2004-2005) - Downloadable PDF File

- Searchable Senate Pork Data (2003-2004) - Downloadable PDF File

- Assembly 2002-2006 and Senate 2005-2006 Pork Spreadsheet

-What Is "Spotlight" And How Do I Use It?

New York Blogwire



        firemonsterrate2

This belongs to you. Take it back...

Amending the State Constitution Isn't Enough

by: Dan Jacoby

Thu Sep 24, 2009 at 15:39:52 PM EDT


In light of the recent insanity, from the defection of Sens. Pedro Espada and Hiram Monserrate, through to the Court of Appeals decision concerning the appointment of Richard Ravitch as Lieutenant-Governor, it is pretty obvious that parts of the state's constitution are in serious need of reworking.

What is not so obvious is that the consolidated laws of the State of New York are in even more dire need of scrubbing.  Many of our laws are obsolete, others are so badly written that their meaning is obscure at best, still others are rendered irrelevant by later laws.  The result is often a confusing morass.  What's worse, even the laws that do have a specific, relevant meaning are often phrased in ways that only a topnotch lawyer can understand.

My recommendation after the jump:

Dan Jacoby :: Amending the State Constitution Isn't Enough
I recommend a blue-ribbon panel be created with the (paid) job of going through all of New York's consolidated laws.

I suggest that the panel consist of 17 members, 4 each from the majority and minority parties of each house of the legislature, and the chair -- someone who is considered to be above partisanship -- picked by the other sixteen members.

The panel would have the power to decide how it will divide the job among its members, how those members will work together, and how often (and where) the entire panel would meet.  The panel's pay scale would be set by the law that creates it.

The panel would make recommendations for changes to current laws.  Where the meaning of a section of law is unclear, the panel should make multiple recommendations, so that each potential interpretation is covered.

The panel would be charged with reporting to the governor and the legislature after six months; that report should give a timeline for completion of the project.  Upon receipt of the final report, the legislature should be required to go into session in mid-September for the purpose of legislating the recommendations of the panel.  Under this plan, the legislature would not be allowed to adjourn until all the recommendations have been acted upon -- in each section covered by the panel's report, either the law would be modified or a vote would be taken to leave the law as it is.

This could take years, but the end result will be a clean set of consolidated laws.  It is a long-overdue reform.

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
A few recommendations... (4.00 / 1)
I like the fact you bring this up Dan. I agree that the constitution needs some fixing, but these laws need to be fixed too.

The panel you propose is a good idea. I think it shouldn't include any legislators, to be honest with you. They are, after all, the ones who helped create these laws. I would rather see an independent group created that is charged with doing this.


Support our troops, not the war.


I couldn't agree more (0.00 / 0)
There shouldn't be any legislators, current or past, although I believe there should be at least a few people on the panel who have been involved in legislative drafting.

In addition, the panel should be able to research the history of the laws, to see when they were created/amended.  Knowing how we got into this mess can only help us find out how to get out of it.


[ Parent ]
I particularly don't want it to have state Senators -- use judges (0.00 / 0)
I mean seriously, you would trust the State Senate to clean up the laws?

I'd rather have a panel of judges and recently retired judges.  The judges are the people who have to deal directly with the unreadability, contradictions, gaps, and so forth in the laws and they'd probably have some strong feelings about how to make it make more sense.

Perhaps representatives of the local governments, who also have to deal with this nonsense regularly, might help.  And other independent people who are concerned with the issue.


[ Parent ]
The federal government has permanent civil servants (0.00 / 0)
I would also note that this sort of thing isn't a "do once".  It has to be done repeatedly and continuously.

The Office of the Law Revision Counsel in the House of Representatives is tasked with the job of cleaning up the law and making it readable and coherent.  They move slowly but continuously.

In the UK the "Law Commission" and the "Scottish Law Commission" perform similar tasks, but with a broader remit: they can recommend functional changes rather than merely wording fixups, although they are still focused on creating coherence.

Ireland's Attorney General's office has a division devoted to similar tasks.

The State of New York deserves such an office too.  I would model it on the UK/Ireland model rather than the federal model; it's very much worth allowing the commission to recommend functional changes.


[ Parent ]
The Albany Project

Please take my Blog Reader Project survey.

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Search




Advanced Search


NY blogs

Politics

10,000 Things
Adirondack Almanack
Buffalo Geek
Buffalo Pundit
Buffalo Stuff
Capitol Confidential
Daily Gotham
Daily Politics
Danger Democrat
Democracy in Albany
DMI Blog
DragonFlyEye
Empire Page
Empire Zone
Gothamist
Gotham Gazette
Gowanus Lounge
Group News Blog
Herkimer County Progressive
Intrepid Liberal Journal
Jason Gooljar
Joshing Politics
Left of the Hudson
Living In Dryden
Lost In The Ozone
McHugh Watch
Nassau GOP Watch
Nasty Letters
New York NewsLadder
NY-13
NYCO's Blog
onNYTurf
Peter King Watch
Planet Albany
Politicker NY
Politics on the Hudson
Reform NY
Rochester Turning
Room 8
Simply Left Behind
Skelos Watch
The Community Alliance
The Fighting 29th
The Robach Files
The Rural Patriot
Tom Reynolds Watch
Troy Polloi
Upstate 2050
Upstate Blog
Upstate Blue
Walsh Watch
WFP Blog

Think Tanks

Brennan Center for Justice Citizens Budget Commission
Citizens Union
Drum Major Institute
Fiscal Policy Institute
New Democracy Project
Progressive States
Taub Urban Research Center

Organizations

Citizen Action
Citizens for Better Government in New York
Common Cause
New York Citizens for Clean Elections
Progressive States Network

>
National Blogs

Politics

AmericaBlog
Billmon
Crooks and Liars
DailyKos
Digby
Eschaton
Firedoglake
MyDD
Open Left
Political Cortex
Senate Guru
Skippy
Swing State Project
Talk Left
Talking Points Memo
The Right's Field

LBAN Network

Agonist
All Spin Zone
AlterNet
AMERICAblog
American Street
ArchPundit
BAGNewsnotes
BartCop
Big Head DC
Blogging of the Pres
BlogACTIVE
Bluegrass Report
Bluegrass Roots
Blue Indiana
BlueJersey
Blue Mass. Group
BlueOregon
BlueNC
Bob Geiger
Booman
BRAD Blog
Brendan Calling
Buckeye State Blog
Burnt Orange Report
Calitics
Capitol Annex
Carpetbagger Report
Chris Floyd
Clay Cane
Cliff Schecter
Comments from Left Field
Confined Space
Corrente
Cotton Mouth
Crooks and Liars
culture kitchen
Cursor
Daily Gotham
Daily Kos
David Corn
Democrats.com
Dem Bloggers
Deride and Conquer
Democratic Underground
Digby
DovBear
Drudge Retort
Ed Cone
ePluribus Media
Eschaton
Ezra Klein
Feministe
Feministing
Firedoglake
Fired Up
First Draft
Frameshop
Greatscat!
Green Mountain Daily
Greg Palast
Hoffmania
Horse's Ass
Hughes for America
In Search of Utopia
Is That Legal?
Jesus' General
Jon Swift
Juan Cole
Keystone Politics
Kick!
KnoxViews
Las Vegas Gleaner
Latino Pundit
Lawyers, Guns and Money
Left Coaster
Left in the West
Liberal Avenger
Liberal Oasis
Loaded Orygun
Mahablog
Majikthise
Make Them Accountable
Matthew Yglesias
MaxSpeak
Media Girl
Michigan Liberal
Minnesota Campaign Report
Minnesota Monitor
MyDD
My Left Nutmeg
My Left Wing
My Two Sense
Nathan Newman
Needlenose
Nevada Today
News Corpse
News Dissector
Newshoggers
News Hounds
Nitpicker
Oliver Willis
onegoodmove
OpenLeft
PageOneQ
Pam's House Blend
Pandagon
People's Rep. of Seabrook
PinkDome
Politics1
Political Animal
Political Wire
Poor Man Institute
Prairie State Blue
Progressive Historians
Raising Kaine
Raw Story
Reno Discontent
Republic of T
Rhode Island's Future
Rochester Turning
Rocky Mountain Report
Rod 2.0
Rox Populi
Rude Pundit
Sadly, No!
Satirical Political Report
Seeing The Forest
Shakesville
SirotaBlog
SistersTalk
Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
Slacktivist
Smirking Chimp
SquareState
Suburban Guerrilla
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo
Talk Left
Tapped
Taylor Marsh
Tattered Coat
Texas Kaos
The Albany Project
The Blue State
The Democratic Daily
The Hollywood Liberal
The Reaction
The Talent Show
This Modern World
Town Called Dobson
Turn Maine Blue
Uppity Wisconsin
Wampum
War and Piece
WashBlog
Watching the Watchers
West Virginia Blue
Young Philly Politics
Young Turks

A Responsible Plan to End the War in Iraq - Click here to add your support

Register to Vote: Rock the Vote, powered by Working Assets Wireless

blog radio

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Subscribe in Rojo

Add the albany project RSS Feed to Newsburst from CNET News.com

Add to Google

Add to My AOL

Subscribe in FeedLounge

Add to netvibes

Subscribe in Bloglines

Add to Bitty Browser

Subscribe in NewsAlloy

Subscribe in podnova

Add to Pageflakes

Get the albany project in your inbox! Just enter your email address

Delivered by FeedBurner

____________________


Active Users
Currently 4 user(s) logged on.

Powered by: SoapBlox